Substituting for macadamia nuts is something you could find yourself doing for a multitude of reasons. It could be the case that you normally keep a stock of them but have found yourself caught short in your time of need. Alternatively, it could just as easily be the case that there’s nowhere in your local area that stocks them.
For many, the reason we search for an alternative is the exorbitant cost of macadamia nuts, the most expensive nut in the world. Whatever your reasons for wanting to find an alternative, we’re here to make some suggestions that can sidestep the cost and the rarity of the macadamia. The macadamia nut may be an incredibly tough nut to crack but finding a substitute for it shouldn’t be!
A Complete Guide to Substituting for Macadamia Nuts
These exotic and luxurious nuts are known the wold over for their rich and buttery taste which is a big hit on dessert menus in more upmarket restaurants. But what if we told you that you could replicate that same opulent flavour at a fraction of the cost at home? Well, the good news is that it’s 100% possible.
Macadamia nuts have a wide range of culinary uses and can also be reimagined in terms of their purposes. Some useful examples of this include: macadamia oil, milk, butter, and flour. Bear in mind that some of the suggestions below won’t be quite so versatile, nor will they have the same nutritional profile. But, they will act as convincing substitutes in a pinch and many may even trick the most refined of palettes. So, without much further ado, here is our rundown of the best substitutes for macadamia nuts:
Hazelnuts are a relatively cheap and easily accessible replacement for macadamia and are generally a decent all-rounder when it comes to baking. They make fantastic cookies (some would argue, better than macadamia) and function perfectly as a topping for a variety of dishes both savoury and sweet.
Though it is true that the texture is slightly more towards the crunchy side of things, there are still quite a few similarities between macadamia and hazelnut – right down to their physical appearance in a chopped state. There are also parallels in their odour and similar tones in their flavour palettes, with a certain buttery-ness being a distinctive feature of both. Naturally, you can find hazelnuts pretty much anywhere you look. However, not all hazelnuts were created equally. One of those that stands head and shoulders above the standard supermarket brands is this:
Nothing beats getting your hands on the raw unadulterated version of any food produce. It gives you the chance to get up close and personal with it, to figure it out, assess what its strengths and weaknesses are. Furthermore, you gain assurance that the extra flavourings put in by the manufacturer aren’t attempting to disguise a mediocre raw product. Plus, you get to decide exactly what you want to do with it!
· Brilliant in its simplicity
· An excellent nut for baking, toasting, and transforming into milk
· Easily available via the already popular Trader Joes
- Texturally different to macadamia
Walnuts are the perfect substitute for when you are trying to replicate the creaminess that macadamia can bring to a recipe. So, if you intend to make a cream, a paste, or a mousse out of the nut, this may well represent the best choice for you.
But, the hazelnut is not limited to just making an adequate creamy-textured replacement, it also has plenty of other tricks up its sleeve. It also works perfectly when toasted and as a topping for desserts. Likewise, it should also be in your considerations if you intend to make cookies or another similar form of bake. Again, these are readily available pretty much anywhere at the fraction of the cost of macadamia. It’s a win-win all round! One particular brand we would recommend for these purposes is this one below:
One thing you may notice about these walnuts is that they are incredibly cheap. Well, don’t be put off by that as it turns out that quality can be bought at a reasonable price. These walnuts are the epitome of simplicity – nothing is added and nothing is removed.
· Beautifully earthy and smooth flavour
· Non-GMO and preservative free
· Wide range of health benefits
· Missing quite a bit of the buttery-ness that makes the macadamia so identifiable
3. Cashew Nuts
Like macadamia nuts, cashews are also renowned for their creamy texture which can make them an excellent substitute when it comes to making sweet treats. In their chopped form they can also bear quite a strong resemblance to macadamia, all the while having a nice rich and buttery flavour.
Cashews also make for an excellent milk too and are relatively easy to come across; not as easy as hazelnuts, yet still comparatively easier than macadamia. As such, we would consider it a reasonably strong contender for the best substitute out there. If you don’t already have some to hand, we would recommend getting a hold of these:
Buying nuts in their raw, unsated, and unroasted form gives you the freedom to use them for a wider range of purposes. For example, due to their raw state, these can be made into milk, butter, or simply roasted to use as dessert toppings or in cookies.
· 100% organically produced
· Not too hard or too soft
· Creamy, buttery, and versatile; an excellent substitute overall
- A bit pricier than our other suggestions
4. Toasted Pecans
Toasted pecans can make a great substitute for macadamia in terms of flavour. They’re quite similar in many regards, with both having a pretty easily identifiable buttery sweet flavour. That being said, the raw pecan doesn’t behave in quite the same manner as its toasted equivalent. A raw pecan will be coarser in texture and therefore quite far removed from the mouth feel of the real deal.
To remedy this, simply toast the pecan slightly, and as the oils within the nut begin to release, they will soften the texture. This is perfect for when you want to substitute for macadamia in cookies as there will be no real change detectable whatsoever – you may even fool your guests. Pecans are far easier to come across than macadamia and cost a pittance in comparison. If you can get your hands on these ones, you’re guaranteed to be on the right track:
It can be tough enough to find pecans that haven’t already been doused in salt and extra flavourings. This is a real pity as the naturally occurring flavour should be considered more than enough and not only that, they are better to cook with in this form. Thankfully, there are a few brands out there that sell this kind of product online, so if there is none available near you it’s not a problem
- Far cheaper than macadamia
- Excellent rich and buttery tones
- No preservatives and non-GMO certified
- Not a great match in terms of aesthetics
We hope that you found this guide to substituting for macadamia nuts to be a valuable and information source as you embarked on a quest for an alternative option. As you can see, there are several decent substitutes out there – one or more of which may be lurking in your spice rack as you read this!
We invite you to review the following questions and answers section for some additional information that just might be of some use to you.
Why are macadamia nuts so expensive?
Due to how difficult it is to successfully cultivate the plant, and the fact that it takes each tree 7 tears to produce a crop, there simply just isn’t enough supply to drive the price down. As recently as 2017, macadamias made the news for a 17% price hike due to these reasons.
Where do macadamia nuts come from?
Macadamia originates from Australia but is now grown in favourable climates around the world, in Hawaii, Brazil, Indonesia and elsewhere.