Just Another Food Blog

Every product is independently selected and reviewed by Well Fed editors, but we may earn commissions for purchases made through our links (no added cost for you)

Best Broiler Pans Review for 2020 – A Buying Guide

Best Broiler Pans Review for 2020 – A Buying Guide

Every cook and every kitchen is different but having the proper tools and utensils makes your job as a master chef that much easier! As you use a broiler pan you’ll start to see the benefits in both your kitchen skills and your clean-up times.

Using a broiler pan makes baking, grilling, and broiling much faster and easier. It uses less oil and drains away excess fat and grease to make for a healthier meal in total. Incorporating a broiler pan into your kitchen arsenal will not only level up your cooking game but give you great added health benefits!

Broiler pans are designed to allow the grease and fat from cooking foods to filter down and away from your meal. This keeps your meal from being saturated with grease and gives it the nice crisp edge any great chef is looking for in your meats and dishes.

This guide is going to take you through the best broiler pans on the market, their pros and cons, and the benefits to each of the different designs. We’ve done the footwork for you so when you set out to buy yourself a broiler pan, your choice will come with ease!

Join us to learn more about broiler pans and how you can incorporate the correct one into your kitchen utensils!

Broiler pans 101

Let’s get started with what exactly a broiler pan is and what how it is typically used.

A broiler pan is a hollow enameled metal plate that is typically made of stainless steel or heavy gauge steel with an enameled shell. There are two pieces; a shallow pan and an upper cooking portion. The cooking portion is ridged with slots that allow the grease and oil to drip down into the shallow pan. Cooking surfaces of a broiler pan are typically 6-12 inches wide and 10-18 inches long.

Broiler pans come in several varieties of materials including enameled steel, enameled cast iron, aluminum, and copper. Some, but not all, of these types of pans have nonstick finishes on them for easier clean-up.

One of the common misconceptions is that a broiler pan and a roasting pan fulfill the same uses. While a broiling pan has a drip pan and a slotted upper cooking area, a roasting pan is a deeper dish that can sometimes come with a lid for roasting meats and vegetables. Knowing the difference between the two will help you keep track as we go through the top roasting pans in our next section!

The Best Roasting Pans Reviewed

Rather than spend hours searching through page after page of reviews, notes, and information, in this section we’ve put together a list of the top roasting pans on the market so you can easily choose the roasting pan that works best for your kitchen!

On your mark, get set, get shopping!

1. Frigidaire Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan

Frigidaire 5304442087 Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan, 1", Blue

View on Amazon

This broiler pan is extremely versatile and comes in a beautiful campfire blue color that is reminiscent of camping out under the stars! The pan measures 15x12x2 which is large enough for almost any cooking project you care to undertake.

The broiler pan only comes in one color and one size but can withstand the broiler temps up to 500 degrees. Made of enamel-coated steel it cleans easily and efficiently despite the typical mess.

For the cost, this broiler pan is one of the better ones on the market. It has positive reviews from customers and the company is responsive when issues are brought to their attention. While not as sturdy as other pans may be, it is hardy and will get you started as you begin your broiling adventures!

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Beautiful coloring
  • Budget-friendly
  • Very simple to use

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • Not as hardy as other materials
  • Occasionally has spots that were not enameled

2. Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan

Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan 246597-1, 12" x 9View on Amazon

This beauty has bang for your buck! Made of stainless steel, the two pieces of this broiling pan are great multi-taskers. The bottom pan can be used for baking or roasting and then the two pieces together form a solid broiling pan.

The stainless steel of this broiler pan is sleek and futuristic looking. Very reasonably priced, the stainless steel broiling pan can be easily cleaned in the dishwasher to make it easy on you after cooking a delicious meal. The pan itself comes in two different sizes, 12×16 and 12×9 so you can choose what will work best for your dishes and your storage spaces.

This is a beautiful option for your kitchen and sturdy to boot!

Pros:

  • Fantastic looking design and style
  • Dishwasher safe for easy clean-up
  • Multi-tasking utensil

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • Can spot if not dried by hand

3. Wilton Non-stick Broiling Pan Set

Wilton Non-stick Broiler Pan Set, 11 x 7-Inch

View on Amazon

Wilton offers a great product for an excellent price! This non-stick coated steel product comes in two pieces, a rack, and a roasting pan, and is ideal for meats and vegetables.

The Wilton pan is 11×7 inches and is dishwasher safe for easy clean-up. The product does not that it’s best to hand wash the pan before the first use to make sure that it is cleaned completely before using with food.

While the item is touted as being non-stick, there is a bit of sticking to the pan after cooking and additional cleaning products are occasionally needed to get it cleaned after use. Ideal for 1-2 people and the cooking they will use it for the non-stick broiling pan serves its purpose at a great price!

Low cost and great return make this a must-have for any kitchen!

Pros:

  • Non-stick surface
  • Excellent price for the product
  • 5-year warranty from the manufacturer
  • Handles on edges for easily lifting food out of the pan

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • Can have some extra food stuck on the product after cooking.
  • The non-stick coating may come off according to reviews

4. Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan 12.75 Inch by 8.5 Inch,BlackView on Amazon

In a departure from the past few broiler pans on our list, this one is porcelain and non-stick with a sleek design for a lower cost. The edges of this design are cupped for easy storage and to make it easier to use for whatever you need!

This broiling pan is 12.75×8.5 and can be used to cook for one or two or a whole crowd! Both pieces of the product are dishwasher safe for easy clean-up. The pan has been known and reported to not quite fit with the grill area that it comes with but the company has a responsive return policy so a replacement is never far away.

This product is simple and easy to use and you get a great product for the cost. The porcelain material makes it easy to clean and take care of. Dishwasher and oven safe, this product can handle the tough stuff and come clean afterward! A great buy!

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Easy to store between uses
  • Excellent price for a well-reviewed product
  • Responsive return policy from the store

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • Not as sturdy as other products
  • Can develop rust

5. Nordic Ware Nonstick Broiler Pan Set


Nordic Ware Nonstick Broiler Pan Set

View on Amazon

Three layers make up this nonstick broiler pan set starting with a carbon steel core and finishing with two layers of aluminum that make this pan completely easy to clean after use and well worth the investment!

An overall solid broiler pan set that sets out to do the heavy lifting in your kitchen, the Nordic Ware broiler pan set has a 15×9 surface area that makes cooking for a few people a breeze. The slotted grate sits on top of the handles to make lifting your food out a breeze.

This broiler pan set is dishwasher safe and comes with just the two pieces, the grate, and the drip pan. A simple design that stands up to the heat of broiling easily. Customers have noted that the holes are only located along the sides of the grate so grease may drip and splash underneath the grate as it’s draining in only a few places.

Nordic Ware brings a strong competitor to our competition today with a simple, sturdy design, and is well worth mentioning!

Pros:

  • Sturdy material and product
  • Multiple uses for the pan
  • Non-stick and dishwasher safe
  • The typical cost for the product

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • Slots only along the edges for grease to drip through
  • Smaller grill grate space than other products

6. G&S Metal Products Company ProBake Teflon Nonstick Bake, Broil, Roast Pan

G & S Metal Products Company ProBake Teflon Nonstick Bake, Broil, and Roast Pan, 3-Piece Set, Charcoal

View on Amazon

While most broiling pan sets have only two pieces, this handy set comes with three pieces for all your cooking needs! Teflon is one of the toughest and best-reviewed types of nonstick pans for cooking. Made from professional grade steel, this product will give you the even heat you’re looking for in a broiling pan.

This broiling pan set is a little smaller than others in our list, coming in at just 8x2x12 for cooking dimensions. The grate lifts out with nifty handles for easy transference to a plate or other surface after cooking is done.

The larger pan can be used for baking cakes or brownies while the smaller pan and grate can be used in conjunction with roasting or broiling in your oven! Cleanup is a breeze with Teflon Xtra nonstick finish on each of the pieces. The set is dishwasher safe but hand washing and towel drying is recommended for the pieces.

Pros:

  • Extremely versatile and easy to use
  • Simple design with easy to use handles
  • Dishwasher safe for an easy cleanup

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • The nonstick coating may start to peel after several uses

7. Rachel Ray 2-Piece Cucina Nonstick Bakeware Crisper Pan Set

Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Bakeware Set with Grips, Nonstick Cookie Sheet / Baking Sheet with Crisper Pan - 2 Piece, Latte Brown with Cranberry Red Handle Grips
View on Amazon

Cooking for a crowd? This broiler set has you covered! The large cookie sheet/drip pan is 10×15 and comes with a removable crisper insert for all your broiling needs.

This set has a unique design and color scheme that will stand out in any kitchen set. The nonstick coating releases any cooked food for a clean finish that makes clean-up a breeze after use.

Both pieces of this set are oven safe up to 450 degrees with rolled edges to make moving the pan easier. Silicon handles on the ends of the pan give you a non-slip grip as you’re moving your meal from the oven to the counter.

This set must be hand washed to keep it clean and working well but the cost is affordable. But the larger cooking area, the baking sheet that can be used on its own, and the non-slip handles on the ends, make it a great option for your kitchen!

Pros:

  • Unique color scheme and design
  • Sturdy and durable
  • Large cooking area for bigger portions
  • A portion of proceeds go to charity

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • Grate sits down in the pan and may be more difficult to get out when hot
  • The temperature range only goes up to 450 degrees

8. Wilton Advance Select Premium Nonstick 17-inch Broiler Pan

Wilton 17-Inch Nonstick Broiler Pan in Gunmetal

View on Amazon

And last but not least, we return to the Wilton product line for their Select Premium Broiler Pan. This larger pan gives you more room to cook and broil whatever you need for your next meal!

The gunmetal color is simple and the design of this Wilton product is a step up from the first one on our list. While slightly more expensive, this broiler pan set is heavier duty and more solid than other pans on the list.

Dishwasher safe is always a good bet and this broiler pan set fits the bill! The entire set is dishwasher safe for easy clean-up. The nonstick surface makes removing your meal a breeze after you’ve finished cooking under the broiler.

Reviews have the finish on this product coming off after several uses hence why it’s at the end of our list here. While the larger than the typical cooking surface is nice, the finish is not as sturdy or complete as many others on our list.

Pros:

  • Larger than a typical cooking surface area
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Heavy-duty interior
  • The bottom pan can serve to bake
  • Great price for the product

Check Current Price on Amazon

Cons:

  • Finish may come off after several uses

A Buyer’s Guide to Choosing the Best Broiler Pan

blank

We’ve shared a lot of great options for a broiler pan in our countdown here! There are lots of different materials for a broiler pan but all are considered nonstick.

These are just 9 of the many options on the market now but don’t worry!

To help you sort through the options you’ll be faced with, we’ve set up a buyer’s guide to run you through the process of buying a new broiler pan. We’ll go through several aspects you’ll need to consider as you search for a broiler pan that works for you and your kitchen.

Not all broiler pans are created equal so knowing what you’re looking for will help reduce the confusion when presented with your options!

Cooking Area

In our reviews above, we talked a bit about the cooking area of broiler pans but here we’ll go over some things you’ll want to consider as you’re looking at broiler pans either online or in the store!

Stop to think and evaluate how many people you’re cooking for, the type of food you’ll typically be broiling or roasting, and how much space you’ll need to cook your food evenly. All of these aspects influence what type of broiler pan you’ll need for your kitchen.

The average cooking area of most broiler pans is 9×13, the standard size of a cake pan or roasting pan. This gives you plenty of area for steaks, burgers, vegetables, and more for between 3-4 people.

Keep in mind the size of your oven as well as your storage space you’ll need for your broiler pans between uses. Whether you take the broiler pan apart or keep it together, you’ll want to make sure you have plenty of room in your cupboards or pantry to correctly store your broiler pans between uses.

Budget

Let’s face it: budget is a huge factor in your choice of kitchen utensils. Depending on how often you’ll be using your broiler pan, you may want a more expensive broiler pan. If this is your first time using a broiler pan and you’ll only use it twice, a less expensive option may be more to your liking.

Broiler pans range from $10-$50 depending on the material and finish for each of the options. Taking the time to read through this list and having an idea of which characteristics you want in your broiler pans will help you narrow down your choices when you include your budget into the process. 

Each of the broiler pan sets on this list is a great option for whatever you might need! Unless you get a solid gold plated broiler pan, none of these options will break the bank for you. But evaluating your own kitchen needs will help you make a great choice.

Oven Temperature

However, you choose to use your broiler pan sets, make sure that they reach the temperature you need to cook food accurately. Some pans are graded for lower temperatures than others.

Double-check your recipes or ideas for recipes to ascertain the correct temperature you’ll need for your meal. Broiler pans that are rated for anything lower than 500 degrees may have a hard time keeping up with high level broils in your oven.

Broiler pan sets list the temperature ratings clearly so you can make a choice that fits your needs!

Color and design

Now for the fun part! The broiler pans set come in several different colors and designs so that you can choose one to go with your kitchen color scheme and design.

Make sure to double-check that every component of the broiler set is safe for the oven. Some broiler sets may come with additional pieces like lids or handles that won’t be able to go into the oven. There’s nothing worse than melting plastic into your oven on accident!

Dishwasher vs. Hand Wash

The convenience of an electric dishwasher is nothing short of a miracle! But it may be too abrasive for many broiler pan sets and take the nonstick finish off of your new product.

Most of the broiler pan sets in our list are safe for the dishwasher but be sure to check and double-check the instructions for whichever broiler pan set you to choose for your kitchen. Dropping money on a new broiler pan set only to ruin the nonstick finish but cutting corners with the dishwasher could be a great tragedy!

While washing your broiler pans by hand can take more time, you’ll be able to get all of the grease, grime, and stuck on food off the set before putting it away. This also protects the finish so you’ll keep nonstick for longer. Make sure, whether dishwashing or handwashing, that you don’t use abrasive cleaners or cleaning utensils.

It’s not a fun chore by any stretch of the imagination but taking the time to hand wash your nonstick broiler pans will keep the finish nonstick for longer!

And the Winner Is…

Now is the moment you’ve all been waiting for: the announcement of our top two broiler pans!

The overall favorite and number one choice are the Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan shared as number 2 on our list. This sleek and futuristic design will look at home in any kitchen and is easy to use and easy to clean. 


Sur La Table Stainless Steel Broiler Pan 246597-1, 12" x 9

The runner up in this little contest is the Frigidaire Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan shared at number 1! This is a super cool design reminiscent of camping gear from when you were a kid! Lightweight and easy to use this broiling pan travels well and holds its nonstick coating well after several uses. It’s compact and stores easily to keep your counters clean.

Frigidaire 5304442087 Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan, 1", Blue

 

Conclusion

Broiling pans come in handy whether you’re just making burgers for your family or cooking steaks for a crowd! The health benefits of letting grease and oil drip and drain away from your food are hard to quantify but give you great tasting food without the grease.

Evaluate the needs of your kitchen and your overall budget before stepping out to shop for a new broiler pan set. Once you know what you’re planning to use your broiler pans you can filter through the aspects of each broiler pan to find the one that works for you.

Whether it’s your first time using or buying a broiler pan or if you’re replacing a beloved utensil, this list will help you narrow down your options and find the perfect fit for you!

Happy shopping and happy cooking!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *